The 3 Questions Students Should Ask Themselves When Vetting Job Offers

Landing the job isn’t the end goal—it’s the starting line.

As career services professionals, we know the exhilaration of securing a job offer can quickly turn into anxiety over making the right decision. And while it’s easy for students to get caught up in the title, the salary, or the brand name, our role is to help them think more deeply.

Because here’s the truth: Not every job offer is a good fit. And one of the best tools students have at their disposal? Asking the right questions—especially when they have the chance to speak with current employees during the interview process.

Let’s move beyond “So, how do you like working here?” and equip students with the questions that actually matter.

1. Can I grow here?

A shiny title and flashy perks are meaningless if there’s no room to evolve. Encourage students to dig into the company’s approach to development and growth.

• Are new hires expected to know everything on day one?
• What happens when someone makes a mistake?
• Can employees share examples of times they failed and how the company supported them?

If the culture treats mistakes as learning moments, that’s a green flag. If errors lead to blame and isolation, it’s worth pausing. Companies that invest in their people—through coaching, feedback, or development plans—are more likely to support long-term career success.

2. Will I be encouraged to keep learning?

The best careers are built in places that champion lifelong learning. Whether it’s formal mentorship programs or informal guidance from managers, students need to ask:

• How do people continue learning here?
• Are there mentorship structures or peer learning opportunities?
• Does the company offer internal training, learning stipends, or time for skill development?

Support for learning isn’t just a nice-to-have. It’s a signal that the company values progress and stays future-focused. And in today’s fast-moving world of work, being in a place that nurtures curiosity and skill-building is key.

3. Can I trust the leadership here?

Trust isn’t built through mission statements—it’s earned through consistent action.

Encourage students to ask employees:

• Does leadership follow through on what they say?
• Are goals and expectations transparent?
• When leadership makes promises—do they deliver?

Why does this matter? Because trust in leadership is one of the biggest predictors of employee satisfaction and retention. If students sense that the company's actions don’t match its words, it may be a sign to think twice.

Empowering Students to Dig Deeper

These three questions—Can I grow? Can I learn? Can I trust?—should become every student’s compass when navigating job offers. They go beyond the surface and help students assess alignment with their personal values and professional aspirations.

As career advisors, our job isn’t just to help students land roles—it’s to help them land well. Encourage them to go into interviews curious, bold, and ready to gather the information they need to make informed, empowered decisions.

Want more content like this to share with your students?

At CareerOS, we help students not just find jobs—but make confident, strategic decisions about their futures. Let’s equip the next generation of talent with the tools they need to thrive from day one.

‍